Sunday, September 04, 2016

Condescension In Drag



My post yesterday about the weepy face emoticon generated some heat, both in comments here on the blog and over on Facebook. As I read through what others had to say I realized that the idea behind that post - that sympathy, and even empathy, are valid emotions but both of which have a complicated and complex relationship with people who have disabilities. Disability itself, as an abstract concept, is linked in the minds of many without disabilities as something at exists for the expression of sympathy and empathy. And then there is pity which is just condescension dressed up in drag.

Yesterday Joe and I were at the 'EX' (Canada's National Exhibition) with the girls, spending hours and hours at the midway. I was watching the girls get off one ride and enjoying the look of sheer pleasure on their faces when, suddenly, the woman in front of them fell to the ground. I caught the fall out of the corner of my eye. Everyone gasped because the woman fell hard, doing nothing to break the fall. When the people with her were helping her up, lifting her up really, it became clear that she had some kind of mobility disability that made walking more difficult for her.

One of the other patrons rushed over to her, arms out, ready to help. With what I don't know because she was already up and brushing off the dust. She looked and saw the woman and said, "I'm fine, I don't need your help." The woman said, "But I feel so bad ..." And that's as far as she got.


The voice boomed out.

The world seemed to stop.


The person rushing over, stopped, dropped the outreached arms, looked hurt and turned and walked away, dejected that sympathy and help had been offered.

Then it was over, the girls were back with us talking about the ride and we moved on t the next one, chatting as we went.

Now here's the thing, and I still don't think I'm going to explain this the way that I think it needs to be explained, people also feel sympathy for people who fall, any one who falls, from an athele to a grandparent. They do. I can and would. But sympathy has a complex relationship to disability. It can feel like pity. It is difficult to trust someone's sympathy because one never knows if it's an emotion engendered by one's self - one's disability or difference, or by the situation - falling in this instance. It is really difficult to trust and because our trust has been violated so often, we may end up rejecting what's honestly offered.

I recognize that's what I may have done yesterday.

Which wasn't my intent. My intent was to discuss this issue which for me is one that I need to deal with. I was wondering if other's had a similar distrust of sad faces, weepy faces or sympathy in relationship to their own lives and the situations they encountered. I'm guessing the woman who fell, might have similar feelings about the whole complex mess. But that's just a guess.


Frank_V said...

I'm always 50/50 on this whole topic. If everyone just stood there, and did NOTHING to help the person who fell, well, I can just imagine the furor. NO ONE has 100% accurate radar to detect sympathy versus true empathy.

Blasting those who dare to help us when we don't want help, without knowing WHY they are helping, is reverse bullying in my opinion.

Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt said...

Other, able, people do not have the constant pressure of not knowing where another slap from the world will come out of the blue.

You do. Gay people often do. Disabled people do - from bitter experience.

It is lovely to think that you might be allowed to start each encounter with another human fresh, without prejudices from previous days, but it's also highly unrealistic. THEY may not be used to being pitied, or despised, simply for who they are and appear to be - so they feel hurt when someone rejects their well-intentioned - and ableist - help. Ableist because it comes from a heart that says, "I'm the helper, always, and other people will need my help, always." Pity, not empathy.

That's the gut feeling. Having to explain not being good enough, or well enough, to do what 'everybody else' does so effortlessly.

I'm exaggerating, of course, but you've made me aware of feelings I suppress all the time in exactly the same circumstances.

Which, for me, means that it's so much easier to accept help from another disabled person! There's an understanding, a 'we're in this together' feeling that is missing with the visibly healthy (who may be carrying all kinds of loads, internally, which I don't know about). A carelessness about doing what they do, because they don't have to worry whether they'll be able to do it.

Healthy, able, non-disabled, normal - whatever you want to call 'them,' they're coming from another place.

Sandra Fleming said...

There are times in my life when I want every bit of sympathy that I can get. To ease the burden of grief, to help to do something when the physical pain is very bad, and just because someone wants to make my life easier.

I appreciate also that it can be perceived as something else especially when ou are dealing with multiple other issues.

I guess I am the type that would offer my assistance and respect your independence and wishes.

Know I need to think more about it but that is why I read your blog each day.

Utter Randomness said...

If only there was a way to make sure people need help before grabbing at them... Oh wait, there is. Ask. People. If. They. Need. Help.

I react badly when people grab at me when I fall, because often those people are the reason I fell in the first place, and their "help" leads to further injury from pulling my joints out of place. Those people, who help without asking, often ignore the first "no thank you" as well. Not to mention the embarrassment of falling in public.